An email header shows spf=pass and dkim=pass, but also dmarc=fail. That is not necessarily a contradiction. The individual checks may pass for your provider’s domains while your own domain appears in the visible From address.
Authentication and alignment answer different questions
SPF checks whether a sending server is authorized for the checked envelope domain. DKIM validates a signature using the signing domain in d=. DMARC also asks whether a successfully authenticated domain aligns with the domain in the visible From address.
DMARC passes when at least one route passes and aligns: SPF or DKIM. Both routes do not have to pass together.
An example with a third-party sending service
Suppose the visible From address is [email protected]. The provider uses [email protected] as the Return-Path and signs with d=mailer.example. SPF and DKIM can pass for mailer.example without alignment with voorbeeld.nl.
Ask the provider which configuration it supports for your domain. Options may include DKIM signing with your domain or a suitable custom Return-Path. Adding an SPF include to voorbeeld.nl does not automatically resolve the domain identity mismatch.
Relaxed and strict alignment
Relaxed alignment can align different subdomains under the same organizational domain. Strict alignment requires the relevant domain to match the From domain exactly. The adkim and aspf settings control this for DKIM and SPF.
Do not tighten alignment just to pursue a higher score. First establish which identity your legitimate services use and what the change would mean for those mail streams.
How to investigate a specific message
Keep a before-and-after example. Include only what is needed for diagnosis and treat message headers as potentially sensitive information.
- Use Authentication-Results from the trusted receiving mail provider.
- Record the visible From domain, smtp.mailfrom and DKIM domains.
- Check both the result and alignment for each route.
- Connect the source to a known service and a responsible owner.
- After remediation, send a new message through the same service.
Why one test does not validate the whole environment
A good employee email result does not confirm that billing, a newsletter or a service desk is configured correctly. Make validation part of onboarding every sending service.
Forwarding and mailing lists can change a message’s route. Investigate that path separately before connecting a DMARC policy change to an alignment issue.
Keep track of alignment with Sender Integrity
When your organization uses several sending services, reviewing alignment requires visibility and ownership. Sender Integrity helps assess observed authentication issues in the context of your sending environment.
With Managed, RHEVOX guides analysis and follow-up with your team or provider. If you first need a focused configuration review, a Sender Integrity Assessment provides an informed starting point.
Sources and next steps
Have alignment issues reviewed with Sender Integrity.
With Sender Integrity Managed, RHEVOX helps your organization interpret authentication results, validate senders and follow up on remediation with your team or provider.